Friday, September 3, 2010

Cupcake Critique: Matty Cakes (Atlanta, GA)

Nice texture and crumb, but the icing didn't blow me away.
So I've driven by Matty Cakes hundreds of times, but had yet to try out this Best of Atlanta bakery. Finally on one of my tasting spree Saturdays (sure beats the gym folks), I was able to stop in. While intent on trying their red velvet, I found myself completely awestruck by a designer purse cake they were making. These fondant covered cakes looked better than some of the bags I've seen on Canal Street. As tempted as I was to order a $140 purse made out of cake, I had to remind myself that I was there just to try their red velvet.

The one thing I like about Matty Cakes is that their prices are super reasonable. Their large cupcake is ginormous and only $2.95. To give you an idea of scale, I took a picture of it on top of a quart of paint, and as you can see, it takes up the majority of its surface area. What they call their "mini" cupcake, is in fact a regular sized cupcake that sells for $1.95.

Now for the red velvet. The cake itself was quite good - the flavor was nice, the texture was moist and the color was a beautiful shade of crimson. I found myself a little disappointed however with the icing. It had a very light whipped cream cheese flavor. It would've been fabulous atop a strawberry shortcake, but it didn't quite stand up to the red velvet for me.

Red Velvet Cupcakes @ Matty Cakes No. 7
A large cupcake from Matty Cakes is almost equivalent
to the circumference of a quart of BEHR paint.
Red Velvet Cupcakes @ Matty Cakes No. 4
What I consider to be the ideal color for red velvet.


  1. Met your parents last night! They told me about your blog!
    Love it.


  2. Thank you! I checked out your blog as well. Absolutely beautiful photography!


Have feedback for the Velveteen Baker? Comment away with any questions, recipes, special requests or just general red velvet adoration.